So, last night I went to my meditation group, and a guy was there who I haven't seen in a while, John. I have very friendly feelings about John, though I wouldn't say we know much about each other. We had a greeting hug, and then, smiling broadly, he said "So, you're losing weight? What's the deal here?"
Well, I never weigh myself, as a matter of philosophical commitment, which I'll get around to explaining one of these days, but there's no way I'm thinner than the last time John saw me. My pants and underwear are all fitting pretty tight. In fact, below the waist, I may be at roughly an eight-year maximum right now.
"I don't keep track of that stuff," I said to John, making sure that my face and voice were genial. "Though I've noticed that the older I get, the more my body fat drains away from my upper half downwards. So my face could be more gaunt even while my thighs are quite substantial." I raised a leg to display my thigh, and John said some genial something or other about his own increased proportions. (Later in the evening he would pat his stomach and suggest that he could sit in as a buddha substitute for our group.)
Assuming John's comment about my looks is sincere, and not just a random piece of well-intentioned vaguely complimentary small talk, there's another possible explanation besides my ever-downward-trending fat. It could be my skin is continuing to tighten up. My surprise accidental thinning-down in 2001 left me with a lot of extra skin, folds and folds hanging off my face, neck, and arms. Sheets of it dangling from my trunk and thighs. Ever so gradually, the skin gets reabsorbed, so that there's this weird growing-younger illusion in the eyes of people who met me anytime later than 2002. And that kind of change in appearance tends to get interpreted as weight loss, even though, in actuality, weight loss mostly leaves people looking older, not younger.
To me it's an obviously ugly thing that small-talky comments about weight loss are always assumed to be acceptable and complimentary. How come other people don't see this as I do? Look at the facts: only shrinkage is polite to mention with respect to other people's bodies; growth in adults is absolutely taboo for comment, unless the body is one's own, in which case the tone is always self-deprecating. In other words, shrinkage is assumed to be always a matter for satisfaction and pride, increase the opposite. But if you look prettier (or more virtuous) in your now-smaller condition, then you must have looked (or been) worse before, when you were bigger. Your present self cannot be complimented without insult to your previous self, to which, in any case, you are overwhelmingly statistically likely to return.
Why would anyone enjoy the feeling that other people in their social circle are collectively scrutinizing their bodies closely enough to observe minor fluctuations, at least half of which (on average) are tacitly taken to be evidence of bad habits?
It's crazy. This is the bad habit, right here, this cultural obsession with "weight." Let's quit it, okay?
No comments:
Post a Comment