Why do regular people—I mean non-manufacturers and -purveyors of processed snacks, beverages, fast foods, etc.—keep singing along with this constant refrain that “there are no bad foods”? Everyone agrees, I suppose that there is such a thing as a bad habit with respect to food and eating, that, for instance, it’s not wholesome for soda, packaged snacks, deep-fried fast food items, etc. to constitute a large percentage of anyone’s daily caloric intake. Whenever it does (and increasingly it does, especially for disadvantaged youth), this is clearly a bad situation. But we’re all supposed to agree for some reason that the products in question are completely innocent of contributing in any way to the problem. That leaves only the individual consumer to blame, then, right? It reminds me of the old slogan “Guns don’t kill people, people kill people.” The food slogan has a second clause too, although it’s always implied rather than stated overtly: there are no bad foods, there are only badly-behaved people who make wrong eating decisions.
If people—individuals of weak will or poor judgment—are always to blame for any damage done to their own health, then there’s no such thing as a systemic problem, never any corporate responsibility for a dangerous product, and no reason ever to address widespread problems with public policy. That’s pretty convenient for vested interests who would prefer to remain unregulated, disclaiming all responsibility for the ultimate outcomes of their economic activity. And in the case of processed food and beverage industries there is an extra convenience in that there is already an easy target available onto which blame can be diverted: fat people. Fat people are widely understood to be leading defective, contemptible lives through their own choice.
I submit that there most certainly are bad foods. Low-nutrient edible products which do not occur in nature but which are highly palatable thanks to the industrial manipulation of their components and which therefore exert an unnaturally strong pull on instinctual drives honed over millennia of evolution in an environment that didn’t typically include anything sweeter than fruit or anything fattier than wild game—these are at the very least dubious, potentially dangerous foods. Eating such things might interfere with our normal cycles of hunger, foraging, and satiety, perhaps eclipsing the pursuit of more nutritious foods. It might mess with body systems (e.g. setpoint) which have a feedback loop to what’s available in the immediate environment. It might constitute a stress on organs like the liver which, again, evolved to handle a “caveman” diet, not the food court.
In childhood, I once read that lab rats offered a choice between nutritious rat chow and white sugar will eat just the sugar until they die of vitamin deficiency diseases. It made quite an impression on me. Later (in teenage-hood) I was talking to a coworker about my distrust of sugar and he went “Huh? But a sugar molecule is just a fructose plus a glucose. What’s the problem with that?” Yeah, I know. I’m not talking about junk food being bad because its main ingredients are toxic at the molecular level. They’re usually not. It’s a question of what happens at the systemic level, when the human body encounters stuff in proportions wildly different from what human bodies got used to encountering over most of the course of the history of our species.